Science-- there's something for everyone

Friday, September 7, 2012

Using teeth to determine handedness

ResearchBlogging.orgClose to 90% of Neandethals were right-handed. Much of this data comes from comparing the muscularity of their arms, which show clear differences. However, arms aren’t the only way you can tell a lefty from a righty. You can also look at that individual’s teeth.

How often have you used your teeth as a tool to hold, pull or tear something? Neanderthals, with their much stronger jaws, presumably made even more use of their teeth. Wear patterns on their enamel confirm this. A right-handed person who routinely uses his mouth as a vise grip will not wear down the same sides of his teeth as a left-handed person. You can try this yourself (though hopefully not to the point of damaging your enamel). Thus, by looking at the scratches on fossilized teeth, you can tell whether that individual was right or left-handed.

Virginie Volpato of the Senckenberg Research Institute Frankfurt and her colleagues examined the teeth and skeleton of one particular Neanderthal specimen (Regourdou 1). They found that using his teeth to determine his handedness yielded the same result as using his arm asymmetry. This strengthens the idea that you can distinguish right from left-handed Neanderthals and also confirms that most of them were in fact righties.
Labial scratches on Regourdou 1’s anterior teeth.

I think the authors go a bit off the rails with their suggestion that the preponderance of right-handedness amongst the Neanderthals indicates that they had language (which is predominantly a function of the left brain). I don’t doubt that Neanderthals did have language, but this seems like a tenuous connection. For one thing, couldn’t there be some other reason most Neanderthals are right-handed? And for another, left-handed people also have language. Perhaps someone with more training in neurology and/or paleontology could set me straight.

Virginie Volpato, Roberto Macchiarelli, Debbie Guatelli-Steinberg, Ivana Fiore, Luca Bondioli, & David W. Frayer (2012). Hand to Mouth in a Neandertal: Right-Handedness in Regourdou 1 PLoS ONE DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0043949.g004

1 comment:

  1. As one of God's Chosen Ones (ie a Sinister Lefty) I think the tooth-wear theory sounds quite logical. there are - as ever - a number of variables that you just can't factor out. For example - for me at least - tasks that involve one hand (writing, throwing etc.)I always perform left-handed, while tasks that involve two hands (holding a bat or knife and fork, digging with a shovel etc.) I more often than not perform as any right-handed person would. Whether this has anything to do with me being left-handed but right-footed I'd love to know.

    (It's also handy for playing cricket as I bowl left-handed but bat right-handed).

    Yes. I am quite odd :)